Is Hewlett-Packard Really Considering a Breakup?

By MSN moneyNOW  FEB 06, 2013 10:25 AM

Maybe, a news report suggests, and this rumor boosted the stock late Tuesday.

 


It will be interesting to see how Hewlett-Packard (NYSE:HPQ) shares react Wednesday after a report suggested the company was considering a breakup.

The report came out after Tuesday's close and, of course, after Dell (NASDAQ:DELL) said it wants to go private in a $24 billion deal led by founder Michael Dell.

The HP news, which came from the Quartz site, was good enough to send shares soaring briefly as much as 11% to $18.43 at 4:30 p.m. ET. But additional reports suggest HP's board isn't close to making a decision. The AllThingsD blog reported one of its sources said HP directors are "not actively studying a plan to break the company up."

That was enough to knock the stock down a bit. The stock ended at $17.05 when after-hours trading ended. It had closed at $16.61 in regular trading, up $.43.

So let us recap. Quartz's report said the HP board "is studying a breakup of the U.S. tech company among several options the directors are considering to obtain maximum value for shareholders."

That's not quite the same as saying it is studying breaking the company up. Period.

In fact, the story went on to say the board is studying a breakup and "the merits of the company staying whole, since a recovery seems to be slowly taking hold."

HP shares are, in fact, up better than 46% since reaching an intraday bottom of $11.35 on Nov. 20.

In addition to writing that a split-up is not yet in the cards, AllThingsD's Arik Hesseldahl wrote late Tuesday that CEO Meg Whitman has maintained "consistently and unwaveringly" since June that remaking HP ultimately means keeping the company together, not breaking it up.

One would think HP's board would be thinking hard about what it will take to make shareholders happy. Oh, and ensure a future in an environment where personal computer sales are slumping in the face of stiff competition from Apple's (NASDAQ:AAPL) iPad and other tablet devices.

The company is still trying to right itself after taking $18 billion in write-offs in 2012, mostly for two deals that proved way too costly.

The stock has been a disaster, falling 44.7% in 2012, 38.8% in 2011, and 18.3% in 2010. In all, the stock is down nearly 79% since its peak close of $78 in April 2000.

HP did study whether to break up the company. That is, in fact, what got former CEO Leo Apotheker fired. He proposed spinning off HP's personal computer business on August 18, 2011. The next day, investors responded with such disdain that the shares fell as much as 23%.

Apotheker was gone in a bit more than a month, replaced by Whitman, the former eBay (NASDAQ:EBAY) CEO and Republican candidate for governor of California.

Editor's Note: This story by Charley Blaine was originally published on MSN moneyNOW.

More from moneyNOW:

7 Facts About America's Youngest Female Billionaire

Americans Are Dumping Their Cars

Michael Dell's Tough Road Ahead

No positions in stocks mentioned.