Who Is Responsible for the Housing Collapse?
None of the parties can be absolved.
In Friday's Wall Street Journal, Nick Tamiraos cited a paper published by the Federal Reserve Banks of Boston and Atlanta that aims to dispel the popular notion that Wall Street, not Main Street warrants the harshest chiding for the financial crisis. Not everyone agrees with the Fed economists' viewpoint, including Madhaus over on Bay Area Real Estate Trends, who isn't convinced that we should let bankers off the hook just yet.
The Fed paper pooh-poohs the notion that we should heap blame on "industry insiders" like mortgage brokers and traders at Wall Street firms like Goldman Sachs (GS), Bear Stearns (JPM), Merrill Lynch (BAC), and Lehman Brothers (BCS) for duping the rest of us into believing that their securitization machine could ensure that the real estate party would last forever. Instead, they propose the "bubble theory" where the real culprit was borrowers' belief that home prices would never go down.
It is easy to see why the paper has sparked criticism from the populist camp. At a time when millions of homeowners still face the prospect of losing their home to foreclosure, piling on and blaming them for causing the crisis isn't a popular viewpoint. It isn't that far off, however: Borrowers are to blame for the crisis, since record levels of demand had to come from somewhere.
But implicating borrowers isn't the same as absolving bankers.
Each side played their role. Wall Street banks widened mortgage underwriting guidelines beyond rationality, opening the market for homes to borrowers that in hindsight had no business borrowing that much money. Mortgage brokers peddled the product, which was endorsed by rating agencies like Moody's (MCO) and Standard and Poors (MHP), while Realtors waived their pom-poms and promised home values would never go down. Borrowers, some by coercion and some by free will, took the bait -- hook, line, and sinker.
Cash poured into the market from abroad, fueling the bubble even as home prices began to wobble. In 2006, I sat in meetings and listened in awe to European bankers who had flown into New York with a single order from bank executives: Put money to work in the US housing market. They didn't understand what they were investing in, and didn't bother to learn. They just didn't want to be left out.
In the final analysis, any assessment of the housing market's collapse that does not implicate all parties, from borrowers to bankers to regulators to lawmakers, is incomplete. Commentators aiming to absolve certain parties are ignorant at best and engaged in willful deceit at worst.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opin=
=3D =3D3D ion about the performance of securities and financial markets by =
the wr=3D iter=3D3D s whose articles appear on the site. The views expresse=
d by the wri=3D ters are=3D3D not necessarily the views of Minyanville Medi=
a, Inc. or members=3D of its man=3D3D agement. Nothing contained on the web=
site is intended to con=3D stitute a recom=3D3D mendation or advice address=
ed to an individual investor =3D or category of inve=3D3D stors to purchase=
, sell or hold any security, or to =3D take any action with re=3D3D spect t=
o the prospective movement of the securit=3D ies markets or to solicit t=3D=
3D he purchase or sale of any security. Any inv=3D estment decisions must b=
e made =3D3D by the reader either individually or in =3D consultation with =
his or her invest=3D3D ment professional. Minyanville write=3D rs and staff=
may trade or hold position=3D3D s in securities that are discuss=3D ed in =
articles appearing on the website. Wr=3D3D iters of articles are requir=3D =
ed to disclose whether they have a position in =3D3D any stock or fund disc=
us=3D sed in an article, but are not permitted to disclos=3D3D e the size o=
r direct=3D ion of the position. Nothing on this website is intende=3D3D d =
to solicit bus=3D iness of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Mi=
ny=3D3D anville mana=3D gement and staff as well as contributing writers wi=
ll not respo=3D3D nd to em=3D ails or other communications requesting inves=
Copyright 2011 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.