Shorts betting against First Solar (FSLR)
The question isn't what's already been done by the shorts, though, but whether it continues as the patten and whether the pattern is specific to First Solar or is a stand-in for the entire solar sector.
The sudden spike in First Solar short bets could be the sign of more to come or could have been motivated by the typical volatile First Solar earnings trade, and as such is a short opportunity already gone.
In the two weeks between Febuary 15 and Febuary 29 -- First Solar reported its earnings on Feb. 27 -- short interest in the solar energy company increased by 8.3%. First Solar short interest reached 31.2% as a percentage of float, and 21.5% as a percentage of shares outstanding as of Febuary 29.
In its earnings, First Solar reported warranty charges related to solar panel performance issues in intense heat conditions. Some First Solar experts see in this revelation another
However, there's also the belief after last year's monumental collapse in First Solar shares that the short opportunity is more or less over, and there is a risk in keeping a short on the stock given the prospect for a larger company to acquire First Solar
If the latter is the case, then this short interest spike in First Solar should settle down when the Nasdaq next reports short interest for the first two weeks of March.
The negative bet on solar earnings is plausible in the fact that Trina Solar (TSL)
On Monday, all of these stocks sold off sharply, with First Solar, Trina, and Suntech down by 5%.
Chinese solar companies that have reported earnings in recent weeks have guided to shipment levels that many analysts see as aggressive, given that all the companies are guiding shipments down sequentially for the first quarter 2012 but up considerably for the full year. Profit levels for solar companies are expected to be slim to zero even if shipment guidance is met, given the gross margin assumptions to which Chinese solar companies are guiding.
Among some analysts, the correct solar bet isn't to be negative on First Solar specifically, then, but simply to bet that all solar stocks retest lows hit in 2011 before recovering again. While First Solar has already set a new 52-week low after its Febuary 27 earnings, most other solar stocks remain above 2011 washout levels.
With the debate over First Solar still going strong, and the essential question of whether this stock has no bottom or whether the shorts are asking to be burned when a larger company acquires it, the next two-week reporting period from Nasdaq might end up being the better info set to answer this question.