Why College Could Be a Bad Investment

By Naresh Vissa Nov 23, 2009 10:15 am
There are cheaper, more productive alternatives.
  • Share this article:
  • A- A A+
In this environment, opportunity cost trumps tradition. For many undergraduates and parents, the cost of going to college is now far greater than the supposed benefits.

“College costs -- along with living and medical costs -- are rising, and salaries are going down right now,” Managing Director of Formula Capital and Wall Street Journal columnist James Altucher said. “College graduates don’t have the same benefits as they did 30 years ago.”

Parents should beware of their child’s intentions. Many students want to spend their parents’ money -- it’s their last chance to go all out.

Now is the time to reflect on prospects.

When potential students think about college, they should ask themselves what they're hoping to get out of it. Analyze their life. Assess their majors. This is a major investment decision. Discuss possible returns, separating anticipation from reality.

“If a student wants to go back to school in their 20s, when they’ve made some money, traveled, and matured a bit, then go ahead,” Altucher said. “But a parent shouldn’t have to spend $50,000 a year for their kid to go to frat parties all day long.”

An alternative to college is becoming an expert at one area and offering your services. The best university in the world is called Google (GOOG). You can learn anything you want on the Internet, free of charge.

Why don’t parents give a quarter of the amount they would have spent on an education to their kid to invest? The cost of starting a business is next to zero. Not everyone is an entrepreneur, but there’s no harm in trying to be one.

“Critical thinking shouldn’t cost $200,000,” Altucher said. “There are other ways to learn that while kids can make money and get experience. Lay your own track. Become an artist, entrepreneur, investor.”

One of the real benefits of a college education is developing a good network.

College students: Imagine where and how you see yourself in 20 years. Then, look at your current friends and picture their futures. If you have trouble doing this, or see something you don’t want to see, chances are you need to start taking your education more seriously.

Michael Jordan once said, “I have failed over and over again in my life, and that is why I succeed.” The sooner you start a business (and fail), the more you learn about the world and even more importantly, yourself.

In the process, you’ll be making more connections in a year than you would have made by being a full-time student for more than four years of your life. By doing this, you’re forced to grow as a human, and you’ll be better prepared for what the world throws at you.

The ambitious kids who know what they want to do and where they want to be, the ones who diligently participate in extracurricular activity, connect with their professors and friends, go to special events and presentations around campus and the city, and find time to have fun: Those ones need to be nurtured and invested in.

“College isn’t for everyone,” Trends Research Institute founder Gerald Celente said. “It’s is a place where I began to learn how to learn. People look at it as the end.”

It matters what and where you get your degree in, but only to open the door. After that, your name and your word will carry you or bring you down. Your GPA and everything else related to education won’t matter.

If you treat college as a luxury item, then don’t be upset after graduation when you’re living in your parents’ home jobless and thousands of dollars in debt.

(For more on the topic of re-examining college costs, see Get Real About Paying for College.)
< Previous
  • 1
Next >
No positions in stocks mentioned.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.


(8)
2009-11-23 11:34:20
!
Excellent article.
2009-11-23 11:48:54
Groundbreaking article
This is the wave of the future.

A college education is obsolete in a world in which new information is constantly being discovered -- as one needs to know it. Learning all the information of the past before one learns the state of the article is a waste of time and is not a prerequisite for learning the new.

Most of the knowledge learned in college are generalizations rather than the actual specifics of a real situation for which the generalization may be invalid -- because the particular, may not fit into a pre-established category of knowledge.

Because of formidable computing capability, it is now possible to learn the specific instead of guessing at which generalization it falls into -- as precision, valid learning instead of broad generalizations that are learning for learning's sake -- rather than a specific and useful purpose.

University education should be regarded as just another form of experience and not the only path to learning and expertise. Obviously, the people who created the field of knowledge, didn't learn it at college.
2009-11-23 12:25:41
Lots of good advice here
The world keeps on getting more and more overpopulated and hence, an awful lot of job competition and don't forget about job losses to automation. Also, jobs are going to places where the labor is cheap, so why bother spending so much money and time in an endeavor that most likely will not land you a good paying job anyways? Indeed, grads from 30 years ago had it much better.
2009-11-24 07:29:11
College
The problem with a college education in the USA is that it simply places you in direct competition with college educated people from all over the world who come here under misguided visa programs that give away American jobs to children of rich foreigners. The uneducated get to compete against illegal immigrants or join the military. I am sick of the mythology that Americans are lazy, stupid and uncreative. We created the computer revolution, the software, the algorithms, etc. out of thin air working 60 hour weeks for often meager pay. Now we are thrown to the dogs in favor of young H1-B visa holders because we are 'lazy', 'expensive', etc. My child used to want to be an engineer, now she drifts aimlessly because she doesn't see the point in preparing herself for a vocation that will be outsourced to India or China, or force her to compete against a tidal wave of foreign nationals applying for the same jobs in her own country. The government of this country is cutting the American people off at the knees economically across the board. For money. More accurately, for bribes. We could have educated a generation of Americans for what we paid to bail out the overpaid leeches at AIG and their buddies who bet double or nothing one time too many. It makes me sick.
2009-11-24 09:41:06
we'll watch
Parents should beware of their child's intentions.

well for us it is rather simple

you can stay rent free at our rental - you still pay the utilities

however CASH donations of any kind are not in the works

student loans - avoid them PERIOD

can afford school without them??? then DON'T GO

a college education USED to be worth something

today it is no longer AFFORDABLE

SEE WHAT GOVT STIMULUS DOES LONG TERM
2009-11-24 13:18:08
i hate to say this when you go got collage ,it doesn't mean find or get a better job many years ago .it was like if you went to collage you got a higher paying job but those days are gone .it little sad .
2009-11-25 01:24:47
College
I beg to differ. The convoluted visa programs keep engineers scientists & doctors out of our country while unskilled labor keeps coming as it finds employment. For decades the US attracted educated professionals and now discourages them. Uneducated &/or illegal immigrants choke out the low-paying jobs and yes, US kids in general feel themselves entitled to the benefits without the effort and are increasingly unqualified to compete with the educated ones, wherever they are,
2009-12-16 13:35:21
Amen - great article. I left a career as a university professor because I realized that, while college professors are typically people who love to learn, they are charged with teaching a majority of students who are not cut from that cloth. It really stripped the joy out of the profession.

You need to know your own child, though, there will be those who will reap huge benefits from their education and those who will squander the opportunity to expand their knowledge base and skill set.

I think kids need more guidance than their parents typically deliver - that is why I have a 22 year old nephew living in my basement, while I help him figure it out. Great kid, I enjoy having him around, and he works hard at my business, he just hasn't quite figured out how to navigate the world.

My experience is that this entire generation is just a bit lost and confused. Even the cream of the crop, some of whom have worked in my business, don't seem able to fully commit to the requirements of being a fully functional, working adult....

This isn't a slam on this generation - I enjoy helping them - just an observation. The world is changing before them, and they don't quite know how to respond.
Subject:
Comment:
Get real-time options trading ideas from Steve Smith, veteran options trader and newsletter author, plus let him show you the way to cut risk and boost your returns through the strategic use of options.  Click here for a free 14 day trial to OptionSmith by Steve Smith.