Five Benefits of Bankruptcy
By Melanie Lindner Dec 01, 2009 7:50 am
Admitting you're under water is the first step toward recovery.
Bankruptcy is a choice most of us hope to avoid. But with the unemployment rate north of 10%, layoffs and pay cuts are now the norm and many Americans are actually finding relief by recognizing their inability to pay off their debts.
The number of bankruptcy filings has skyrocketed in the past year.
In the 12-month period ending September 30, 2009, 1.3 million non-business bankruptcy petitions were filed, up 30% from one million non-business filings over the previous 12 months, according to the latest data from the administrative office of the US Courts.
Business bankruptcies are on the rise, too. Lehman Brothers, Circuit City, and some 59,000 other businesses filed for bankruptcy protection in the 12-month period ending September 30, 2009, up a whopping 52% year-over-year. Some, such as Lear Corp. (LEA), General Motors, and Charter Communications, managed to emerge from it.
Of course, even when the collection agent is pounding at your door and you can't pay the mortgage, electricity, cable, and credit card bills all in the same month, bankruptcy should still be your last option.
Before meeting with a lawyer to determine whether you even quality for bankruptcy, Mathew Paulose, a Manhattan-based bankruptcy attorney, suggests exhausting all other options before turning to the court.
Ask your friends and family to loan you money; try to negotiate with your creditors; determine whether a legitimate debt consolidation firm can help; work as many hours as you can, even if that means picking up another job.
If and when all those efforts fail, the bankruptcy court will be your last standing friend.
Non-business bankruptcies are generally filed under either Chapter 7 or Chapter 13.
In a Chapter 7 filing, the individual debtor (or couple) turns over all their assets -- save for a few exemptions like your home, clothing, furniture, and a small amount cash on hand as designated by your state -- to a bankruptcy trustee who then liquidates the assets and distributes the proceeds to your unsecured creditors. Chapter 7 debtors generally get their debt release within 90 days of filing their petition.
In the less commonly used Chapter 13 procedure, a debtor with a steady income agrees to contribute a portion of future earnings to repaying creditors a fraction of the total amount owed over the next three to five years. The debtor maintains control of their assets, but doesn't get discharged of any debt until the repayment plan is completed.
To determine whether you qualify for bankruptcy, your attorney will conduct a detailed evaluation of your total assets, liabilities, income, and expenses. The attorney will file a series of forms known as a "means test" that measure your income and the number of people in your household against the median income for the same size household in your state.
If your income falls below the median, your petition is likely to get accepted and you'll be discharged of your debt, assuming it’s great enough to qualify.
However, there are other qualifiers that a trustee will evaluate, too. For instance, if you're filing for a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you'll only qualify if you have enough excess income to cover a reasonable payment plan.
A trustee will also factor in any prior bankruptcy filings. Chances are you won't be granted a Chapter 7 debt release if you've filed successfully in the past eight years; Chapter 13 can be repeated after just two years.
The number of bankruptcy filings has skyrocketed in the past year.
In the 12-month period ending September 30, 2009, 1.3 million non-business bankruptcy petitions were filed, up 30% from one million non-business filings over the previous 12 months, according to the latest data from the administrative office of the US Courts.
Business bankruptcies are on the rise, too. Lehman Brothers, Circuit City, and some 59,000 other businesses filed for bankruptcy protection in the 12-month period ending September 30, 2009, up a whopping 52% year-over-year. Some, such as Lear Corp. (LEA), General Motors, and Charter Communications, managed to emerge from it.
Of course, even when the collection agent is pounding at your door and you can't pay the mortgage, electricity, cable, and credit card bills all in the same month, bankruptcy should still be your last option.
Before meeting with a lawyer to determine whether you even quality for bankruptcy, Mathew Paulose, a Manhattan-based bankruptcy attorney, suggests exhausting all other options before turning to the court.Ask your friends and family to loan you money; try to negotiate with your creditors; determine whether a legitimate debt consolidation firm can help; work as many hours as you can, even if that means picking up another job.
If and when all those efforts fail, the bankruptcy court will be your last standing friend.
Non-business bankruptcies are generally filed under either Chapter 7 or Chapter 13.
In a Chapter 7 filing, the individual debtor (or couple) turns over all their assets -- save for a few exemptions like your home, clothing, furniture, and a small amount cash on hand as designated by your state -- to a bankruptcy trustee who then liquidates the assets and distributes the proceeds to your unsecured creditors. Chapter 7 debtors generally get their debt release within 90 days of filing their petition.
In the less commonly used Chapter 13 procedure, a debtor with a steady income agrees to contribute a portion of future earnings to repaying creditors a fraction of the total amount owed over the next three to five years. The debtor maintains control of their assets, but doesn't get discharged of any debt until the repayment plan is completed.
To determine whether you qualify for bankruptcy, your attorney will conduct a detailed evaluation of your total assets, liabilities, income, and expenses. The attorney will file a series of forms known as a "means test" that measure your income and the number of people in your household against the median income for the same size household in your state.
If your income falls below the median, your petition is likely to get accepted and you'll be discharged of your debt, assuming it’s great enough to qualify.
However, there are other qualifiers that a trustee will evaluate, too. For instance, if you're filing for a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you'll only qualify if you have enough excess income to cover a reasonable payment plan.
A trustee will also factor in any prior bankruptcy filings. Chances are you won't be granted a Chapter 7 debt release if you've filed successfully in the past eight years; Chapter 13 can be repeated after just two years.
No positions in stocks mentioned.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.
(5)
Reply
2009-12-01 08:36:36
Food for thought
Hi Melanie,
Thanks for the article on the benefits of a BK. I will reference readers over to this article when I address the topic in my column! Did you experience this personally? I am glad you mentioned that it not the first option, as many people start to think it is an "easy way out" of a big debt pile when they are feeling desperate and/or overwhelmed. It is never an easy decision to make, and ought to be considered only as a last resort. Well done!
Thanks for the article on the benefits of a BK. I will reference readers over to this article when I address the topic in my column! Did you experience this personally? I am glad you mentioned that it not the first option, as many people start to think it is an "easy way out" of a big debt pile when they are feeling desperate and/or overwhelmed. It is never an easy decision to make, and ought to be considered only as a last resort. Well done!
2009-12-01 17:15:26
Food for thought
Hi Jessie,
Thanks for your comment! Fortunately, I have not gone through a bankruptcy. However, I've talked to many individual and business debtors who were at their wits' end before filing and found relief through the process. As you noted, it is not easy, nor is it a loophole to get out of debt; but for those who use the bankruptcy court appropriately it can be a savior.
Thanks for your comment! Fortunately, I have not gone through a bankruptcy. However, I've talked to many individual and business debtors who were at their wits' end before filing and found relief through the process. As you noted, it is not easy, nor is it a loophole to get out of debt; but for those who use the bankruptcy court appropriately it can be a savior.
2009-12-01 21:58:13
How about some reasons *not* to file for bankrupcy...
Such as...
1. You made a commitment and gave your word to pay back a loan. Bankruptcy should absolutely be the last resort because the only thing you really have in this life is how you've kept your promises.
2. Employers, insurers, and landlords pull credit histories. It may or may not have a big impact on your career and living plans if there's a bankruptcy that you need to explain for the next 7 years.
3. It may not be so easy to actually accomplish a "wipe the slate clean" bankruptcy. I'm kinda surprised that you don't discuss the impact of the newer bankruptcy laws here. It's much, much harder to file for Chapter 7 anymore as an individual. Student loans, by the way, are almost never cleared away in any form of bankruptcy.
4. By taking the easy way out, you don't learn any new habits. People get into credit card debt by overspending. Hitting the reset button without doing the work to get out of debt only encourages old bad habits.
Despite my rant above, I'm not against people going bankrupt. Bankruptcy is an important mechanism that keeps economies moving.
I think, though, folks considering bankruptcy should have done enough work to be okay with telling people that you've been in bankruptcy. The urge to hide the matter, to me, is the one of the telltale signs that you haven't been serious about getting out of debt or changing your habits. Our society is a bit too quick to dismiss shame as important information about yourself. We need it that to get better. And if you've honestly done what you can to get better, no shame is necessary (or felt).
1. You made a commitment and gave your word to pay back a loan. Bankruptcy should absolutely be the last resort because the only thing you really have in this life is how you've kept your promises.
2. Employers, insurers, and landlords pull credit histories. It may or may not have a big impact on your career and living plans if there's a bankruptcy that you need to explain for the next 7 years.
3. It may not be so easy to actually accomplish a "wipe the slate clean" bankruptcy. I'm kinda surprised that you don't discuss the impact of the newer bankruptcy laws here. It's much, much harder to file for Chapter 7 anymore as an individual. Student loans, by the way, are almost never cleared away in any form of bankruptcy.
4. By taking the easy way out, you don't learn any new habits. People get into credit card debt by overspending. Hitting the reset button without doing the work to get out of debt only encourages old bad habits.
Despite my rant above, I'm not against people going bankrupt. Bankruptcy is an important mechanism that keeps economies moving.
I think, though, folks considering bankruptcy should have done enough work to be okay with telling people that you've been in bankruptcy. The urge to hide the matter, to me, is the one of the telltale signs that you haven't been serious about getting out of debt or changing your habits. Our society is a bit too quick to dismiss shame as important information about yourself. We need it that to get better. And if you've honestly done what you can to get better, no shame is necessary (or felt).
2009-12-02 12:13:14
How about some reasons *not* to file for bankrupcy...
Amy, when a person has reached a place in his or her life where bankruptcy appears to be the only option left, the decision to do so is a FINANCIAL one, not a MORAL one. It is HARDLY the "easy way out" as it comes with a very high COST. Further, to say that no shame is "necessary" (or felt) is a telltale sign that perhaps you have neither the empathy nor the experience with people who have suffered dire financial straits---whose causes may not necessarily be within a person's control. Death, disability, divorce, lawsuit, loss of a business or a job can all be contributing factors to a family's Dark Night of the (Financial) Soul.
As for any readers who are still considering filing for bankruptcy, keep in mind, for the sake of your financial self-esteem, other people's judgements of you is more a reflection of them than it is of you. {SMILE} Good Luck.
As for any readers who are still considering filing for bankruptcy, keep in mind, for the sake of your financial self-esteem, other people's judgements of you is more a reflection of them than it is of you. {SMILE} Good Luck.
2009-12-02 13:30:38
How about some reasons *not* to file for bankrupcy...
"Amy, when a person has reached a place in his or her life where bankruptcy appears to be the only option left, the decision to do so is a FINANCIAL one, not a MORAL one. "
I agree.
However, how someone gets to the point of bankruptcy, how it's handled, and behavior after the fact are *all* moral issues. I've come to believe that how people handle money is merely a reflection of the value system that governs the rest of their lives.
I try very hard not to judge people by mere facts (they went bankrupt, in debt) because I don't know their complete circumstances. As you mention, all sorts of circumstance lead and feed into bankruptcy. I completely understand good luck has a large part to do with my current level of solvency.
Experiencing bad luck does not mean, however, that we all get a free pass morally for failing to plan for a rainy day or past undisciplined spending. I have certainly had my share of bad luck, too.
Truthfully, I have learned more about myself in the moments that I was not happy with me than when I was trying to boost my "self-esteem". Experiencing (but not dwelling) on negative emotions such as shame and anger have been very important in my life journey to date. As you state, the only person you have to live with in the end is the person in the mirror. I'm still working on that person, as we all are.
I agree.
However, how someone gets to the point of bankruptcy, how it's handled, and behavior after the fact are *all* moral issues. I've come to believe that how people handle money is merely a reflection of the value system that governs the rest of their lives.
I try very hard not to judge people by mere facts (they went bankrupt, in debt) because I don't know their complete circumstances. As you mention, all sorts of circumstance lead and feed into bankruptcy. I completely understand good luck has a large part to do with my current level of solvency.
Experiencing bad luck does not mean, however, that we all get a free pass morally for failing to plan for a rainy day or past undisciplined spending. I have certainly had my share of bad luck, too.
Truthfully, I have learned more about myself in the moments that I was not happy with me than when I was trying to boost my "self-esteem". Experiencing (but not dwelling) on negative emotions such as shame and anger have been very important in my life journey to date. As you state, the only person you have to live with in the end is the person in the mirror. I'm still working on that person, as we all are.
Get real-time options trading ideas from Steve Smith, veteran options trader and newsletter author, plus let him show you the way to cut risk and boost your returns through the strategic use of options. Click here for a free 14 day trial to OptionSmith by Steve Smith.
Copyright 2009 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved

















