Sorry!! The article you are trying to read is not available now.
Thank you very much;
you're only a step away from
downloading your reports.

A Word of Warning About Commodities


Commodities appear more attractive in rough times than in good times. But remember that booming commodities don't reflect their fundamentals alone.


I love movies. They're American. Hollywood may be the most important influence this country has ever had and ever will have. I'm no left-winger, and I get just as irritated as anybody else when some actor shoots off his mouth about "climate change," but the signature on what comes out of the Left Coast on celluloid is as red, white and blue as Sam Adams or Betsy Ross. Nobody else does it like the USA.

Having thus vented my spleen, I've never understood why Gordon Gekko's "greed is good" speech takes top bill over "Larry the Liquidator's" impassioned exhortation to stockholders near the end of Other People's Money regarding the seductive nature of a rising share in a declining market. It's simply brilliant:

This company is dead.

I didn't kill it. Don't blame me.

It was dead when I got here.

It's too late for prayers.

For even if the prayers were answered
and a miracle occurred...

...and the yen did this
and the dollar did that...

...and the infrastructure did the other thing,
we would still be dead.

You know why?

Fiber optics.

New technologies.


We're dead, alright.

We're just not broke.

And do you know the surest way
to go broke?

Keep getting an increasing share
of a shrinking market.

Down the tubes.

Slow but sure.

You know, at one time...

...there must have been dozens
of companies making buggy whips.

And I'll bet the last company around
was the one that made...

...the best goddamn buggy whip
you ever saw.

Now, in the case of commodities, we're not necessarily talking about rising shares in declining markets. We also need to be specifically mindful of the distinctions between spot commodities, the companies that mine (or otherwise produce feedstocks and raw materials), manufacturers (for which the play would be stocks or bonds or derivatives), and the futures markets -- they all behave in related ways, but for unique sets of reasons, and they are anything but monolithic.

But here's the seduction that can kill you, and it goes to the very core of what makes people in the middle of a bubble complacent enough to get wiped out when the bottom falls out. Commodities are commodities. Each in its own right, they're essentially the same (yes, I am aware of grades and purities but I emphasize "each in its own right"), and that means distinctions and competition in the marketplace revolve mostly around price, which in turn revolve around supply, demand, etc.

But there are huge macro factors, too. In robust economies, there is little talk about commodities unless inflation becomes a problem, or unless a large exogenous event occurs (e.g., the Arab Oil Embargo, 1973). That's because boom times tend to accompany stable currencies, low borrower default rates, adequate employment and income trends -- thus favoring equity/fixed-income investment and enterprise-oriented capital formation focused on creating value in new and creative ways (e.g., the technology sector). While commodities figure into evolving economic sophistication, and importantly so, they're still commodities. Stability makes commodities sleepy.

Commodities earn far greater attention when the bloom is off and uncertainties are on the rise. That's when the alarm bell rings and commodities wake up.

When central banks around the world are scrambling through the mechanisms of monetary inflation to keep the wheels on the wagon, stave off deflation, save the financial system and its subsegments deemed "too big to fail," and prop up confidence about that which undergirds enterprise, then the whole perspective changes from prosperity to scarcity, from growing the pie to fighting over the slices.

We are in such a latter phase now but it's easy to overlook, given the rising stock market. And the mood is very skeptical. Did we overpay on TARP, TALF, stimulus, and the rest? Most people think we did, especially when they look at the unemployment rate, weekly jobless data, and recollect on phrases such as "green shoots" and when those acorns were supposed to have become mighty oaks. So we can see the "economy of scarcity" part, and while we can also see the increased action in commodities, we're still seeing what appears to be a pretty healthy situation for stocks (although bonds have sold off lately, despite Fed QE I and QE II, and we may well look back upon that in time to come as an important precursor signal).

These are the breeding-ground ingredients accompanying shifts from financial to hard assets, and we see it in everything from gold to oil to copper. Gold is an amazing story in itself, but numerous lesser-known commodities (11 of them, to be precise) outpaced gold's excellent performance during 2010:

Performance of Gold in 2010 Chart

No surprise then, many are talking about "commodity bubbles."

Are We in a Commodity Bubble?

Are commodity prices already overdone? Like everything else, it depends. Each commodity has its own story -- amply demonstrated by the chart above.

But let's return to Larry the Liquidator's fine speech for some guidance about market shares and expertise.

If you've confined yourself to losing your mind in euphoria of price appreciation, you're the bubble and it's in your head.

On the other hand, if you explore the wisdom of such things as rising shares in declining markets, then you're focusing on fundamentals and acting rationally and getting prepared for what makes sense in your future buying and selling decisions for any particular material or issue.

But most of all, remember this: Commodities appear sexier in rough times than in good times because they are investors' way of voting against currencies and financial assets (call it increased macro/micro ratio). The price action can be both startling and tremendous. But booming commodities don't reflect their fundamentals alone; they reflect a combination of those fundamentals and some quantity of premium that indicates a "no vote" on governments and financial systems. You want to cull out the noise and focus on fundamentals in order to make sense of what will otherwise be a distorted and misleading picture.

The Internet Treasure Trove -- It's Time to Try Some Sushi

I'm amazed by what's available in information thanks to the World Wide Web and the ubiquitous connectivity we've come to take for granted. And you don't need Julian Assange to get really good stuff. Google and a good vocabulary, along with knowing what you're looking for and why, is quite enough to keep you busy and well-informed.

One of the big problems with the Web that I've encountered -- and I suspect I'm not alone in this -- stems from "old habits die hard." I open the same tabs and windows almost every day. I need to. After all, I need to be informed about certain things and to stay up-to-date. That means I have eight or nine Yahoo Finance tabs open almost all the time, which collectively provide me the latest price and other information for a universe of 138 stocks and several indices. Covering all that stuff, I feel pretty informed and acquainted with the relevant important factors. That's not a good mood for inspiring "trying new things." You have to consciously try new things -- just like the day you worked up the nerve to have your first platter of sushi. Remember that?

So here's what I do to fight off the rut. I think about topics worthy of investigation. That's part of the reason I write for Minyanville.


Titanium is a perfect example. Because I'm interested in the company Titanium Metals Corp (TIE) and its stock, I decided to do some comprehensive "Googling." I focused on business cycles and industry consolidation.

Titanium is one of those things that sounds pretty sexy in the world of commodities. It's not a precious metal but it's a very useful one, and its many applications include other sexy subjects such as defense weaponry, aerospace, and advanced metal fabrication. These include spy planes, the Boeing (BA) 737 and 787, guided missiles, high-tech wiring and circuitry (including aspects of the smartphone genre).

Titanium's integration with carbon and other lightweight composites in aircraft (and other) manufacturing form another array of many other interesting and cutting-edge subjects. As an example, one might wonder whether composites could displace titanium. One day that might conceivably be a possibility but it isn't true now; in fact, for the present the use of one tends to increase the use of the other, and vice-versa. I'll skip the details of that interesting subject but it's out there to investigate on your own, and it's rather fascinating.

Too Sexy for My Shirt (As in, "Losing It")

Bottom line: Titanium is a sexy subject. And that's bad. Because when people start thinking about sex, they generally lose their minds and dismiss rationality. And that leads to stupidity and costly consequences. Where money is concerned, you don't want to do that.

Here are some very in-depth things I found looking into titanium, along with some brief comments about what I found.

The first is a press release from PR Newswire, not what I usually think of when I'm looking for in-depth information on a topic. Rules, however, are proven by their exceptions, to coin a phrase, and this exception, to paraphrase Fiorello LaGuardia, an idol of times past , is a beaut. In this case, PR Newswire is pitching a report titled "Titanium Metal: Market Outlook to 2015 (5th edition, 2010)" in a press release dated October 19, 2010. The press release is so comprehensive -- ironically, an attempt to tease the reader into a purchase -- I declined to order the report it hawks. Plus, I'm cheap, and the report, published by Roskill Information Services (UK), is 337 pages long.

Here are some quotations from that release:

  • "Global supply of titanium is forecast to increase by 20% in 2010 to around 150,000t following a break in the strong growth cycle from 2005 to 2008 when titanium sponge production increased from 104,000t to 176,000t. The growth from 2005, which saw large volumes of new and rehabilitated sponge production come on stream, was partly driven by a surge in demand from the aerospace sector, but also by growing demand for titanium in chemical plant in China. Chinese output of titanium sponge increased fivefold between 2005 and 2008."

  • "In late 2008, the global economic slowdown and delays in the production of high-titanium content aircraft such as the A380 and B787 caused a sharp decline in titanium demand. At the same time, new sponge plants in the USA and Japan, initiated in the earlier boom years, were coming on stream. In both 2009 and 2010, titanium sponge capacity was surplus to demand and producers delayed further expansions, idled plants and (in China) closed smaller uneconomic plants. In 2010, China has been the main engine for growth and production in that country is again growing strongly with several new large-scale sponge plants under construction."

  • "The easing of world supply of titanium sponge has resulted in sponge prices dropping steadily since 2006 and the market is likely to be overhung with surplus sponge capacity until at least 2012 or 2013."

  • "In 2009, production of titanium sponge was confined to six countries, in order of output, China, Japan, Russia, Kazakhstan, USA and Ukraine. Many of the larger sponge producers have downstream operations producing titanium ingot and mill products, but others have played an important role as merchant supplies of sponge. In 2010, UTMK in Kazakhstan, one of the leading merchant suppliers of sponge, started melting ingot on a trial basis and has entered into an agreement with Posco to set up a titanium slab plant in eastern Kazakhstan. This could have a significant impact on the dynamics of global sponge supply."

  • "There are now 18 companies producing titanium sponge, of which nine are in China, compared with just two plants a decade ago. Many companies have announced further expansion plans, although some are now on hold. If all expansions come on stream capacity could reach 400,000tpy by 2015. The four new projects in China, together with expansions in Japan and Russia, could add 85,000tpy to the total."

  • "In 2010, titanium ingot melting capacity is nominally 340,000t, 85% of which is located in Russia, USA, Japan and China. Melting capacity is at least twice that of sponge output, due in part to the practice of double and triple melting, and in part to the use of scrap in the melt feedstock. The USA dominates the production of mill products for the aerospace industry while producers in Japan and China focus on industrial and consumer applications for titanium."

  • "The global market for titanium mill products in 2009 was about 100kt compared with 130kt in 2008. On a global basis, demand for mill products is divided between aerospace (39%), industrial (48%) and consumer (13%) uses, but there are significant regional variations. In the USA the aerospace industry accounts for more than 70% of demand while in China industrial applications dominate. The rapid growth of industrial markets for titanium in China has shifted the balance away from aerospace, but demand for the higher grades of sponge and ingot is still heavily influenced by the cyclical nature of the aerospace industry."

  • "Demand is forecast to grow at 6%py to 2015, resulting in a market for 140,000t of mill products requiring up to 200,000t of sponge. Industrial markets outside the USA and North America will grow at about 9%py and the commercial aerospace market in North America and Europe will grow at around 8%py, albeit from a low base in 2009, provided that the delayed development of the A380, B787 and A350 gathers momentum and the build rates of the B737 rise. The growth in demand from the aerospace sector will come partly from increased aircraft production, but the main driver is the increased buy-in weight of titanium per aircraft. The greater use of composites, more compatible with titanium than aluminium, has resulted in significant increases in the use of titanium in landing gear, ducting, wing carry through structures and weight-critical forgings."

  • "The main industrial applications for titanium are in chemical/petrochemical plant and in heat exchangers; this sector has exhibited very strong growth over the last five years, almost entirely due to the rapid expansion in construction of chemical and power plants in China."

  • "The market for sponge, unwrought metal and mill products is characterized by long-term supply agreements between major producers and consumers, without the involvement of traders. However, the shortage of sponge in 2006 led to more activity on the spot market and prices for sponge, which had historically hovered around US$7/kg, rose to US$30 by the end of that year. As more sponge capacity came on stream the market started to weaken and by 2010 sponge prices were generally below US$10/kg. Prices of ingot and mill products were also well below the peaks reached in 2006/7. Scrap prices, on the other hand, strengthened in 2010 as supplies had dwindled in 2009 as manufacturing declined. Prices for sponge are not likely to move significantly above US10/kg until 2014 when the surplus capacity should be absorbed."

My comments: Supply trends are up over the long term -- despite a notable hiccup or two -- and those trends are especially worrisome at the top of the food chain: titanium sponge, which is the highest margin space but also subject to wild and unpredictable demand trends. Not unexpectedly, China is a looming and increasing factor (Russia and surrounding "stans" have already been there to dump product whenever they feel like it) -- just like that country seems to be in everything else. Demand for sponge appears robust at the moment but that demand is highly leveraged on aerospace and commercial aircraft. We know about the problems with the Boeing 787 and associated delays. We might be wondering about the political shift rightward in the new Congress and its effect on defense expenditures indirectly related to titanium. More companies, in an increasing number of countries, are getting involved in production, and all of them are interested in the "big enchilada": sponge. Aside from aerospace and defense, there are interesting and important applications in the petrochemicals sector.

Another report that caught my eye came from the Inspector General's Office -- perhaps better thought of as a set of recommendations than as a report as such.

This document, ominously dated October 29, 2009 (the 80th anniversary of The Great Stock Market Crash of October 1929) essentially observes the effect of US Department of Defense orders on titanium prices and suggests the importance of locking in long-term supplies based on index-driven trends so as to ameliorate price spikes. In checking with the Inspector General's Office, I've learned that the document is alive and well in their memory banks and has been appropriately circulated and generally well-received.

As for official implementation, that seems to be an area of question marks, and one of the things you will observe in reading this report, if you do, is that there is a language, tone, and culture all to its own in the world of government and procurement -- something I discovered on the Grace Commission so long ago I refuse to divulge the time frame. But that's important with titanium, because much of the business is concentrated in the defense/military sector.

But I can tell you this: After reading these documents, there was nothing related to sex on my mind and, if I wasn't fully informed about titanium, I was certainly experiencing no bubble-oriented euphoria, either.

Finally, my last investigation was a look at some stock charts and graphs, especially for Titanium Metals Corporation. They are interesting and I've decided not to share my conclusions about that. I will point to some recent price and trading activity worth noting if this company/industry is of interest to you. And I further suggest some in-depth probing regarding insiders, their "chains of ownership" (both personally and via business entities), interlocking directorates and officerships, background history, and recent filings.

I found the this report quite informative in this regard -- especially in the "history repeats itself" department -- but reach out, as there are many places to look around, and the Web is a bottomless reservoir if you successfully fight "the rut."

Additional Laughs

There's another report I discovered that gave me a good laugh but not much otherwise. It began with the sagacious observation that, concerning titanium, "excess capacity remains a barrier to entry," which -- much like Larry the Liquidator's "Show me a company with a rising share in a declining market, and I'll show you the last buggy whip manufacturer" -- conveyed "this industry sucks," but in a much less entertaining way.

Obviously, excess capacity is a barrier of entry. It means there's more of something, and the capability to produce even more on top of that, than the world wants. But "barrier of entry" makes it sound like there's something in the way preventing interested parties from getting involved, when in fact "excess capacity" reflects the fact that the industry would have been better off if there had been something to keep competitors out once upon a time when demand was more consistently keeping pace with supply. The net benefit, however, in such less exciting situations, is to the end user in the general phenomenon of supply overhang keeping a ceiling on costs and prices.

Navigate Your Own Research Path

So there you have it, and I hope I've set you down a path to investigate the topics of commodities, the circumstances surrounding shifts from financial to hard assets, and whatever micro industries and enterprises you may find appealing, informative, and profitable. As the French say when they're going biking -- today on bicycles that sometimes contain liberal doses of titanium -- bonne route!

No positions in stocks mentioned.

The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opi= nion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the write= rs whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers ar= e not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its ma= nagement. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a reco= mmendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of inv= estors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with r= espect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit = the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made= by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her inves= tment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positio= ns in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. W= riters of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in= any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclo= se the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intend= ed to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Min= yanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not resp= ond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.

Copyright 2011 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.


Busy? Subscribe to our free newsletter!