The Global Financial Crisis Is Not Over

By Laurie McGuirk Sep 23, 2009 1:30 pm
There are many more hurdles to overcome -- and Bernanke should know this.
  • Share this article:
  • A- A A+
Friedrich A. Hayek (1899-1992), Austrian economist, author and 1974 Nobel Prize-winner for Economics wrote: “With the exception only of the period of the gold standard, practically all governments of history have used their exclusive power to issue money to defraud and plunder the people.”

The global financial crisis is over. Politicians, central bankers, economists, and mainstream market commentators have jubilantly declared it so. Everything is okay again; the equity markets are up 50%.

Yet these same experts were oblivious to the looming debacle in financial markets, notwithstanding the incontrovertible evidence so glaringly obvious to those that cared to delve beyond the superficial. Why now should such unsubstantiated, historically ignorant, and fundamentally illogical conclusions be met with anything other than skepticism and guarded optimism?

I don’t share their opinion. I opine that this is but the early stages of this monetary quandary. This whole crisis is a simple monetary issue, not an economic issue -- a fact that appears foreign to most.

Indeed, following the two previous periods of wildly excessive monetary growth in the twentieth century, 1920s and 1960/70s, one ounce of gold purchased the Dow Jones Index.
Today it takes ten ounces. Further, each of these periods led to significant distortion in economic activity, dysfunction in banking, and currency markets with resultant unprecedented official/government intervention. Ultimately, these interventions led to the complete disintegration of the currency system of the day, producing massive increases in the gold price.



I contend that one ounce of gold will again buy the Dow -- I don’t know at what level, just that it will. It may be that, due to continued extreme monetary inflation, the Dow hits 30,000. That same monetary inflation will drive gold exponentially higher as investors seek refuge from glaringly obvious currency debasement by the accumulation of hard assets rather than paper promises.

Similarly, the Dow could be 3000 as the crisis deepens with spending contraction leading to nasty corporate earnings disappointment, no matter the stimulus. The capacity for gold and silver to absorb significant capital flow is small indeed, given the global investment pool. And for gold to double or triple from here wouldn’t take much of China’s multi-trillion dollar reserves. My point being that I expect precious metals to outperform all other asset classes on a relative basis.

Given that the typical “balanced portfolio” is effectively 70% (or more) equity market exposed, it’s not difficult to comprehend why I assert that a quantifiable and transparent precious-metals portfolio is a prudent and essential risk diversifier at all times, none more so than today. The global macro economic picture is ominously bleak, notwithstanding the best efforts of officials to circumvent the simple economic law of supply and demand.

The recent 50% rally in equity prices is fundamentally challenging for my firm, but we understand that markets don’t move in straight lines. And as Keynes famously remarked
“Markets can stay irrational for longer than you can stay solvent.”
No positions in stocks mentioned.

The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.

Copyright 2009 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

(19)
2009-09-23 14:31:48
Excellent
Laurie,
Excellent. You discuss the many factors, that the pundits (and even fund managers) seem to be ignoring. For example, people are still not talking about the debt bubble, just amazing.
2009-09-23 15:42:31
great article
thanks Laurie,
A great , timely article although the timing could have been earlier--ie Sydney in 1840--truly, we never learn, and when either the sages before us are totally ignored, or our own reluctance to see the cliff in front of us urges us onward, the result is the same, and it is where we stand now. Lots of food for thought and a great historical insight. I hope for lots of very smart people to survive the aftermath of our folly
2009-09-23 15:51:01
Outstanding Article
Thank you for a terrific article. One of the bests I have read on Minyanville. Great work.
2009-09-23 16:18:12
"I ask why the Dow would behave any differently given the conditions in 2009."

The Dow would behave differently because besides the ongoing credit bust, the rest of the world is also undergoing economic bust. In Japan's case, it was the premier exporter of the world and the US was still booming. So, in a sense Japan's bust was to some degree alleviated.

The present bust? No such luck. So, I guess the comparison should be closer to GD 1929.
2009-09-23 18:50:17
Intertwine worlds
I love gold prophets. You can't rationalize gold as currency and use arguments based in paper currency, it sounds insane. So, what would an ounce of gold be worth if there was no currency to compare it with? Oh, that's right… it would be worth its weight in goods and services.
With out sending us back to the Stone Age, just how would I buy Microsoft stock if gold were the currency…mail the contracted weight? LOL… That only leaves one modern day solution, a digital gold transfer like banks conduct.

The solution begets the same problem, Trust in the system, except now its not just trust in the central bank its trust in all the metal producing companies of the world, but they would never lie…. Oh wait, didn't that happen to silver in the 80's when silver portfolio's tanked because they found a huge silver deposit, and it turned out to be a lie.

If we had been privileged to have silver based currency we would have experienced a simultaneous currency debasement and commodity deflation.

On a side note haven't you ever thought China's buying of gold is just a necessary step to floating their currency.
2009-09-23 19:38:46
Laurie
Nice to hear from you again, flashback to the embryonic stage of this debasement when you wrote more often. Many high net worth folks here are and have been moving money out of the country for fear of capital controls. My gold broker is taking multiple 1000oz orders from them. They see it and that is why they have high net worth. Good Luck to us all.
2009-09-23 19:45:51
Intertwine worlds
Adam,

Its very simple. My old and worn pre -1964 Washington quarters can be sold all day long for about $3.00. If you know the difference between those coins and the ones that came after you will realize very simply what is and has been happening. If I want Microsoft stock I can sell metal for paper and put the trade on. You might be surprised that some of us with chunky metal positions , actually own Mr. Softee too! If MSFT trades below 15 I would sell some metal and buy it. I will not sell metal to earn interest in a bank or buy bonds. I do own some Asian bonds from the plunge and wont sell them just yet. Wealth preservation and value are what I am after, and metal has done its job for me during this debt bubble.
2009-09-23 22:22:46
Intertwine worlds
I completely understand, but you still have to realize that you're not using the metal as a medium for exchange; you're using the paper as a medium for exchange. Please read my post again, the author's arguments make no sense.

You may think gold is a good hedge against inflation, but would you have said that in 2001 at $200 an ounce?
2009-09-24 03:07:40
Great article ..
Why does everyone look at the past recessions/depressions for comparison and guidance,and say it's like 1929 or 1974 or whatever time? What we have seen so far ,seems like no other time period for the USA.The triple bubble , saving the worst for the last , will force us to change ,hopefully not at gun point. The Chinese politburo must be laughing very hard at us behind closed doors; When rates rise ,they will finish us off.Since we owe alot more than msft's mkt cap and there isn't enough physical gold to serve as deep storage for "money", our land and resources will end up as Chinese REO'S. Maybe we should sell Hawaii to them as a 3.5 % down payment, and hope things get mo' better .
2009-09-24 09:16:07
Intertwine worlds
Adam,

As you likely already know, gold/silver was our coinage. The $20 Gold Double Eagle was worth $20 for a very long time, and now it is worth at least $1100.00. When our nation was most productive and prosperous gold/silver was the medium of exchange. You can still move to paper and I dont care that its not currently the medium. In 2001 as today I would say that it has not been a very good inflation hedge. It seems that it has performed the best during very high inflation, and deflation, as well as during currency debasement. I became aware in 2001 that the Fed was never going to stop blowing bubbles via bailouts (until forced to do so by the market) and I saw a 20 year bear market in hard goods and gold/silver was likely the investment of a lifetime at tose prices. There was total apathy toward it at that time. People simply forgot about it during the 20+ year paper chase.
2009-09-24 10:40:30
Hard to Refute any Points
Perhaps a lost decade ala Japan is in the cards.

Glad to see that somebody remembers the definition of inflation!
2009-09-24 12:01:19
Excellent article!!! thanks!
Laurie, this is one of the best articles I read in a while... thanks! I have never thought about physical gold before -- once I read at the end of last year that:

- the Fed has pumped 14 trillion of "free" money into the insolvent banking system (under all sorts TALFs, MALFs, etc.) to create the illusion of solvency (abolition of the 'mark to market' was a nice additional step to cover up the fraud)
- that the banks are sitting on 1-2 million foreclosed homes to try to keep the prices from plunging further (they can do it now, since they have no issue with money -- it is freely flowing from the Fed, just ask) - they do not need to worry about "public reporting now" since mark-to-market is cancelled as of April
- that China, Russia, Brazil, S. Africa, Germany and a whole bunch of other countries are not-so-silently any more switching their trade transactions into own currencies, away from the dollar
- that finally, there is a mega-fraud committed by the Fed, with silent approval from the US Gov -- when the Fed gives trillions to Banks AND NOW also Investment Banks at 0% financing, who in turn go and buy US T-Bills are 2, 3, 4% (speaking of money-machines - free 2-4% on trillions, not bad) and then report astronomical profits to the gullible public (I wish I could get a few trillion of worthless paper from the Fed myself and then finance the US government debt -- suckers -- I am sorry -- tax-payers would pay me a nice cushy interest, that I would then use to pay myself a nice bonus for a job well done)...

well, when I read all that over the last 6 months... I thought anything but paper USD is where I should be. Gold is the best option. And I agree, physical Gold, not some paper transaction with GLD who may or may not be buying physical stuff (similar to Fed, they are not really audited by anyone credible, not sure even WHO would be credible at this stage to do the audit -- not the US gov for sure, maybe Chinese government since they have a few trillions to lose)...

anyway, thanks, this is a really well-thought, well researched article -- the example from Sydney is quite an amazing find, reads eerie like the insanity of the last 5 years, no less. I share your “hopeâ€, for the sake of my own young kid, but I definitely am not betting their future on my “hope†and a bunch of incompetents (or frauds) in the Fed and the US gov.
2009-09-24 12:42:21
GLD?
The spot price of gold has increased somewhere in the neighborhood of 150% in 4 years. While arguments can be made that gold is not a bubble, it sure seems that investors are being reeled in to yet another version of performance chasing. First tech stocks, than real estate, now perhaps precious metals?
2009-09-24 13:23:11
Intertwine worlds
Looks like you timed the market right, and a good investment tends to beat inflation. One can even say you bought at an end of a metal bust cycle and are now reaping the rewards of the metal boom cycle.

As far as an inflation hedge, that would depend on management of whatever is being inflated and your time frame on the hedge.

I have seen some numbers that say a gold ounce should be around $6000 when relating to monetary policy; this would make gold a bad hedge to monetary inflation because it trades for only $1000.
2009-09-24 13:40:30
GLD?
Brett,

It certainly is getting attention and it will more than likely end in a huge blow off as all secular bull markets are prone to do. So far the time to buy is the death plunge. We have had a few so far during this metal bull and according to Kevin Depew we may be on the brink of another one. It is very hard to buy when and if this happens. I had very large exposure during the plunge last year but I looked at interest rates and the FED and decided my thesis was totally intact and it was due to forced selling of everything including gold. I was able to buy during the plunge and it did not feel good doing it. Look at GSS, GG, NXG,NSU moves off the lows. It is very volatile and difficult to hold through the volatility. I could not sleep without it!
2009-09-24 13:55:58
Intertwine worlds
I was lucky on the timing but the thesis was solid. At the time I was thinking of what Jimmy Rogers says about investing, something like - "find a pile of money in the corner that nobody wants and pick it up". At the time silver had a over a decade long base from 4.50-5.50 and all silver miners from the 80's bubble extinct.

I am sure other areas have done better. I remember bubblevision types saying that "oil is the new gold" a year or two back as well as saying copper is better than gold. I think copper did out perform gold during some of this time. I can easily hold 30k worth of gold in my pocket, but would struggle with 10k of copper, as I am a little guy. I can only make large investments when I have simple math and real conviction behind my thesis, or I would get spooked out of my position. I never owned it before 2001 and look forward to selling, but I would imagine a 6% plus yield on TNX would be a minimum area for me to begin thinking about it. I could easily take another beating but emotionally I am prepared for this. It is not an investment to get rich on, but rather I look at it as a defensive position against our insane Fed, and I dont want to be poor because of them. Time will tell. Good Luck!
2009-09-24 20:32:17
Real Clear Politics
Hey - a link to this story to Real Clear Politics.

You got someone's attention.
2009-09-30 12:18:55
To be more precise,
It's TWO lost decades, and counting.......
2009-09-30 21:39:32
GLD?
Yeah, I love Mr. P but when he pointed out that Dollar bears are at 93% my reaction was why so few. In Jan 1865 the Confederate dollar was worth 17 cents but continued on to zero. If you waited 140 years the Confederate dollar was worth less than 17 cents accounting for inflation.

Gold is doing a bit better than the Confederate dollar - for how long nobody knows. But then the South lost a war to Capitalists, not Marxists.
Subject:
Comment:
Get real-time options trading ideas from Steve Smith, veteran options trader and newsletter author, plus let him show you the way to cut risk and boost your returns through the strategic use of options.  Click here for a free 14 day trial to OptionSmith by Steve Smith.