Data Summary Shows the US Economy Is in Jeopardy, Part 1
An overview of all the factors at play leads to one inevitable conclusion.
The economy is at one of those crossroads where something is going to happen. Whether that will be a positive or a negative is often difficult to tell because at any time one of those "black swans" could land in our midst and change everything. Plans are fluid and and forecasting can be quixotic. That said, I believe we are at a critical point, and the US economy is heading for a fall.
To understand what "tomorrow" might be, we need to look at today and try to tie those threads together. Here is my analysis step by step, and you can decide if you agree with my conclusions.
I have been looking at a lot of data reports in terms of an overall view of the economy. I apologize for all of the charts and data, but they offer some insight into trends.
Both the Producer Price Index and the Consumer Price Index have shown modest price increases, but may be trending negative.
Producer Price Index:
On a 12-month basis, finished goods have gone up 5.9%, intermediate goods up 8.3%, and crude goods up 12.6%. However, the recent trend is down, as the above chart shows.
Consumer Price Index:
Consumer prices declined 0.1%, and core (less energy and food) went up 0.1%. On a year-over-year basis, prices have increased 3.5%, but that is down from 3.9% the prior month, mainly due to energy costs.
Industrial production as measured by shipments showed a 0.7% gain in October, and the 12-month index was up 3.9%.
The important factory sector output was up 0.5% in October and up 4.1% for the 12 months. The only negative here, and it is a significant one, is that new orders are flat, but may not be declining:
The more telling ISM Manufacturing Index shows some weakness:
The capital goods sector has been showing strong growth:
Business sales and inventories are also steady:
But note that these numbers are nominal, not adjusted for inflation.
Retail sales and food services were up 0.5% for October, and 7.2% year over year. Again, these numbers are not adjusted for inflation. They are steady but have been flat (±) since August 2010.
Wages and Earnings
Real wages continue to be weak. While real wages increased 0.3% in October, that was after a CPI adjustment ((earnings +0.2)+(CPI -0.1%)). On a year-over-year basis, real earnings are down 1.6%. "An unchanged average workweek combined with the decline in real average hourly earnings resulted in a 1.7 percent decrease in real average weekly earnings during the same period," according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
Bank credit conditions are still sluggish.
Consumer credit increased at an annual rate of 1.5% in the third quarter. Revolving credit decreased at an annual rate of 3.25%, while nonrevolving credit increased 3.75%. In September consumer credit increased at an annual rate of 3.5%. Revolving credit is credit card debt; nonrevolving debt is mostly auto loans and student loans. Generally, consumer credit has been rather flat except for auto loans, which have been up and down, but mostly up:
What has changed is that commercial and industrial loans have grown, especially at small domestic banks. Look at the Fed's H.8 commercial bank commercial and industrial (C&I) loans in 2011 (note: I modified this chart to fit):
(Note that "Other consumer loans" are mostly auto loans. This consumer credit data is slightly different than the Fed's G.19 data on consumer credit, above.)
What we see is that C&I loans took off starting in the first quarter of 2011. While the data for large domestic banks shows steady C&I loan growth since the fourth quarter of 2009, small domestic bank C&I lending shot up in the first quarter of 2011, from zero base to $20 billion:
Even more surprising is that average loan size for small banks increased from about $100,000 to almost $650,000. One might conclude from this that the credit freeze is over and small banks are lending and small to medium business enterprises (SMEs) are borrowing, thus indicating a recovery.
What is happening?
The main reason for this sudden increase in loan activity is competition. Ever since Dodd-Frank, banks have been scrambling to figure out how to make more money, as many credit card and other account fees were prohibited in an attempt to protect consumers. One way to offset that loss is to gain more business customers, and there has been a scramble by both large and small banks for SME customers.
Small banks have the most to gain or lose in this competition because SMEs are their territory. So they are pursuing customers. Many also believe that there is a window of opportunity with favorable spreads and thus the timing is critical to expand business before that window closes. The initial beneficiaries seem to be the banks in the $5 billion to $10 billion asset range, which are classified as small banks. Keefe, Bruyette & Woods, an investment bank specializing in services to the banking sector said:
[Damon DelMonte, an analyst with KBW Inc.'s Keefe, Bruyette & Woods Inc.] said banks reporting loan growth are taking a bigger slice of the pie, but the pie isn't getting much bigger. "We're not of the belief that the demand for new loans is really ramping up," he said. "It seems like it's more of a shifting of market share. Smaller banks are going to benefit at the expense of larger banks."
This was also confirmed by the Fed's October 2011 Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey on Bank Lending Practices, where they reported increased competition, but that loan demand was weak:
I will explain the significance of this data further on.
On the international scene, imports were actually down slightly, which was seen as a positive by most analysts (I see it as a negative):
Exports have been a substantial driver of the economy ($2.117 trillion):
International Capital Flows
The Treasury International Capital Report shows us that money continues to flow into the US seeking refuge mainly in Treasuries:
Here is a summary of the above data:
2. Prices are starting to decline both at the producer and consumer level. Oil prices are likely to decline as worldwide economic activity slows. But, as we know, political shocks from producers can alter this forecast dramatically.
3. Retail sales, adjusted for price inflation, continue to be flat to declining.
4. Credit conditions are still tight at the consumer level, and business credit still suffers from lack of demand.
5. Exports have been a primary driver of the economy and have rebounded substantially post-crash as a result of a devalued dollar.
6. European economic problems have caused a significant influx of money into the US, and that has been parked in Treasuries.
Here is a summary of other data I feel is important and that I have recently discussed:
2. Real disposable income is falling.
3. Personal savings have fallen from a post-crash high of 5.8% in June 2010 to 3.6% as of September 2011 because consumers are using savings to fund consumption.
4. GDP is static rather than growing, and the latest third-quarter boost will likely not continue. It is likely that the third-quarter report will be revised downward.
5. Auto sales are related to pent-up demand and are not likely to be sustained.
6. The top 5% of earners account for 37% of all consumer spending, and it is they who are supporting consumer spending. I call this a "bifurcated economy." There is no broad-based consumer spending rally.
7. Household debt ($13.9 trillion) is still historically very high and has not been substantially reduced.
8. U.S. sovereign debt is 100% of GDP ($15 trillion and growing).
9. All government spending (federal, state, and local) constitutes 45.6% of GDP.
10. The euro crisis will have a substantial impact on the rest of the world, including the US. That is difficult to predict, but we'll know very soon. According to recent data, the world is heading into recession in almost all economies.
11. The federal government is currently running a $1.3 trillion annual deficit.
12. Unfunded liabilities for Social Security, Medicare, and prescription drug (Part D) are $116.4 trillion and growing. This does not include the pending problem with student loans (Sallie Mae) or obligations to government-sponsored enterprises.
13. The MF Global (MFGLQ.PK) problem is indicative of a declining economy. It is likely that in a growing economy, MF Global would have been able to ride out its crisis. In a declining economy, company weaknesses tend to be revealed, as with Lehman. That creates market uncertainty.
14. Oil prices have risen from $40 a barrel post-crash to $110 a barrel in April 2011, and presently are at $97 a barrel. Such oil price increases are associated with and often presage recessions.
15. Bank balance sheets are still weak because they do not book asset values at market, they seem to not properly book troubled loans, and they are encumbered by a substantial amount of malinvested assets that have not been liquidated.
16. 47 million Americans (15%) are on food stamps; 48.5% of the population lived in a household that received some type of government aid in the first quarter of 2010.
17. Americans are pessimistic about their future and the future of America, according to almost all recent polls.
18. An angry and disaffected population in America is potentially politically dangerous.
What is important when looking at the data is to spot trends rather than specific numbers. I have what I believe is a healthy skepticism about the reports from the multitude of federal agencies that I follow on a regular basis. They are often revised and probably understate the negatives. That is especially so with price inflation. Many of the reports are in nominal numbers rather than adjusted for official price inflation. If they are adjusted for inflation (chained), their baseline is a recent year. Many analysts put great emphasis on specific numbers, but quantifiable data is ephemeral and probably "gamed." Look at the trend.
Reminder: This is part one of a two-part series. The second half will be published on Minyanville on Friday, November 25.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.
Copyright 2011 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Daily Recap Newsletter