Op-Ed: What Happened to the American Dream?

By Minyanville Staff Dec 30, 2008 11:15 am
Founded on the merits of hard work and intellect, in many instances it's been reduced to one of materialism and greed.
  • Share this article:
  • A- A A+
Editor's Note: James Quinn is a senior director of strategic planning for a major university. James has held high level financial positions with a retailer, homebuilder and a university in his 22-year career.


Historian and writer Jame Truslow Adams wrote in his 1931 book, Epic of America:

“The American Dream is that dream of a land in which life should be better and richer and fuller for everyone, with opportunity for each according to ability or achievement. It is a difficult dream for the European upper classes to interpret adequately, and too many of us ourselves have grown weary and mistrustful of it. It is not a dream of motor cars and high wages merely, but a dream of social order in which each man and each woman shall be able to attain to the fullest stature of which they are innately capable, and be recognized by others for what they are, regardless of the fortuitous circumstances of birth or position."


Mr. Adams penned these words in the midst of the Great Depression, the worst economic crisis in our history. It’s timely to reflect on these words, as it appears that the American Dream is slipping further out of reach for most Americans because of the actions of the politicians running our government and the bureaucrats running the Federal Reserve. And if this dream is lost, it will truly mark a turning point for our great Republic.

Those with ability -- who have earned a better life through their hard work, intelligence and integrity -- should be attaining a higher position in the social order. Instead, our government is rewarding those Americans who have taken unwarranted risks, made careless decisions and willingly chosen the course of excessive debt to climb the social ladder.

As the politicians scurry to save capitalism through the use of communism -- defined by Webster’s as “a system in which goods are owned in common and are available to all as needed” -- more Americans are becoming disheartened.

George Bush, Henry Paulson and Ben Bernanke decided to seize money from the vast majority of Americans who lived within their means, utilized debt sparingly, and worked hard to get ahead, and give it to the most appalling disappointments in our society. They’ve shoveled billions to banks that operated their businesses like gambling parlors, and hundreds of millions to people who bought houses with no money down, interest-only mortgages and fraudulent loan applications. They’re now rewarding automakers who made the wrong vehicles, paid 30,000 workers per year not to work, and have only been able to “sell” cars by giving them away with 0% financing to any sucker who could sign on the dotted line.

These acts make us more Communist than China.

Now, commercial developers are trying to pony-up to the taxpayer trough. These egotists used immense amounts of short-term debt to overpay for malls, office towers, hotels and apartment complexes. But the rental income on these properties could never cover the interest expense on the debts. They’ll only generate income if another developer comes along who’s foolish enough to overpay for the same assets.

The market was flying high as the MBA geniuses on Wall Street were able to work their magic by slicing this debt into tranches -- getting it rated as investment-grade paper by criminally-negligent Moody’s and S&P, and reselling it to gullible investors throughout the world.

The jig is up. According to the Wall Street Journal, $530 billion of debt will come due in the next 3 years, with $160 billion due in 2009. Of course, in the America of today, yesterday’s bad business decisions – such as those that enriched executives like Vornado Realty’s (VNO) Steve Roth, who received accolades from the business press -- are cast aside. Just use the “Too Big to Fail” excuse and all is well - the American taxpayer will come to the rescue.
No positions in stocks mentioned.

The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.

Copyright 2009 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.



(14)
2008-12-30 12:08:01
Excellent article. Public financing of elections is not a panacea but the Supreme Court has ruled for the entrenched elite that this concept is illegal. Can we stop our elected officials (the ones we get to choose from) from being bought by lobbyists? Ron Paul gets limited cverage by the major media. Perhaps a new libertarian candidate can harness the power of the internet. Obama claims to have done so, but more than 50% of his money was raised from the entenched elite.

We will see more American dreams shattered with half of all IRA's gone up in smoke and housing prices continuing to fall. We will start all over again and perhaps be better off for it.
2008-12-30 12:36:03
Stairway to Heaven!
Brilliant! Required reading for anyone with the time to take their night-vision goggles off the neighbor's daughter's breast implants.

As for the single mom whose $1.7 went pffft. There are regulated hedge funds--- they are called mutual funds.
Hedge funds grew out of a perceived need for something that could do more than a mutual fund.
Hedge funds don't need regulation more than they need people to do due diligence before investing. Same with FDIC--- invest at 7% for a CD--- shurely shomething musht be wrong?!?
Manage YOUR risk, people, because the regulators do not care more for your money than you.
2008-12-30 12:49:52
Stairway to Heaven!
Agreed, a great article. Wish it were front page news in every newspaper. And I like you had to chuckle at the example provided on who was hurt by Madoff. Sure, I feel bad for everyone taken in by criminals but if you have 1.7 million you had better be playing it safe on the risk-reward front and you certainly need to notice that they didn't have the standard audits and safeguards in place of regulated funds.

Heard of a local library assistant working in retirement just for fun. Lost over a million in the market meltdown--our leaders have convinced the people that markets always go up and that they have the answers and have managed to convince even people who knew the old American Dream better that the get-rich-quick dream was possible for everyone and a better one at that.

Everything in this article was spot on.

If we need to have a scorched earth to start over, well, so be it. I'm ready for a soup line but the wealthy elite are not, and that, my friends, is why they will do everything that their wealthy elite status allows them to keep them where they are at the expense of everyone else. The Fed only cares about inflation in wages--they said it themselves. They want to avoid deflation at all cost. Because both of those things mean they don't make any money and they lose, BIG TIME. They are fine with the rest of America losing at their expense but they have never had to lose like this in the last 80 years. They will do whatever it takes to reinflate this, even if it means destroying America and debasing the dollar.

The sheeple will continue to believe them because the wealthy elite control the message, daily. They literally have ensured that what they've been telling us in the last 20 years of debt creation is so burned into the American brain that the sheeple will continue deferring all decision-making and ceding power to the same wealthy elite that have taken it all already.
2008-12-30 13:19:00
"My Dad toiled for 42 years as a truck driver for ARCO"

All of our fathers and grandfathers who worked and saved and sacrificed all the while living in little crackerbox houses and driving used cars were fools! God bless them for building this country and all but what did they think they were doing working so hard for so little money? An honest days work for and honest days pay? What a crock!

Something for nothing...that's the ticket. You go ahead and sell your soul to the company if you want...I'm going to get mine.

I mean, Cindy had it right. Why shouldn't middle class single moms with three kids be worth 1.7 million with three investment properties? Shouldn't we ALL be rich? Isn't that the true American dream!

Or maybe not.

Maybe the American dream morphed into a delusion. Maybe the American Way of Life was not only unsustainable but immoral.

The people at the top obviously got a lot more (they always do) but is that really the explanation for the current crisis? Look at history. A society can support 5% of its population being greedy, arrogant gluttons (it always has) but what happens when this number grows to 50, 60 percent or higher? Is this still feasable?

When the magic black box of capitalism and debt were keeping everyone in this country fat and happy (while over half of the rest of the world's population was forced to live on less than two dollars a day) no one seemed to have many questions.

Why so glum now bunky? Surely it can't be because our chickens are coming home to roost.

I mean that was one of those old fashioned sayings we used to hear from our grandparents...and we all know how dumb they were!





2008-12-30 15:37:50
Excellent article
I think that the American dream will survive in some form.
However, it may be that it will not be denominated in American dollars due to the litany of offenses against the dollar that your excellent article has highlighted.
2008-12-30 16:45:10
I'm convinced that the majority of Americans are decent human beings who simply want a fuller life and a legitimate opportunity for advancement.
Disagree.

I am 62 years old. I have seen a lot. I have interacted with thousands of people. Those people with a "certain nobility of character" are a tiny minority, way less than 10%. The vast majority will lie, cheat, and commit any villainy. They are ruled by their lusts, greed, fear, anger, self pity, and hatred. They have, long ago, thrown away their honor.

Horrible.
2008-12-30 18:41:09
super article...i wish someone would tell our beloved politicians
my house is paid for, i drive a 14 year old car, mom and dad never owned a new car in their lives...and neither did i. my credit cards are current, i tried to save up something until i became disabled....and now i have trouble with food and medicine....but according to our 'rules' i cant get help....not that i want any.

so much for the great economy and its variants....exept for the lightbulb police, showing up in theaters near you in 2012.

and i dont go to theaters either....but congress voted itself a pay raise equal to 1/3 of my income for the year....thank you very much...happy new year to all...and GOOD LUCK
2008-12-30 22:29:23
bye bye 2008
Thank you for penning an article that sums up my thoughts on the subject rather well; I'll link to this often as I email friends and relatives when they worry over why I'm so agitated by all that has transpired this year. I too wish this article was front-page news everywhere.
2008-12-31 03:06:13
Weak effort by the Minyanville Staff
Pretty wimpy stuff. The key conclusion is that this blow up has been brewing for at least 25 years. Many people pointed out the obvious results along the way, but the collective wisdom of our democracy allowed us to put ourselves in this position. Did Ron Paul get any votes? Doesn't matter, it was too late anyway.

The Jefferson foreign policy was to lend vigorously to the Indian tribes on the east side of the Mississippi such that we could foreclose and relocate them to the West.....China learned well.

I am certain some wealthy publican in Sumeria wrote a similar rant during the credit collapse in 10,000 BC.
2008-12-31 11:24:17
Weak effort by the Minyanville Staff

Which begs the question...

if all of this is so obvious then why do we seem powerless to do anything about it?

I believe the majority of the people in this country are in favor of most of the policies that Ron Paul espouses. However, they didn't vote for him 'because he can't win'! They apparently don't trust themselves to pick a leader and so have passed this power onto the greedy and corrupt...and their tool the mainstream media.

Somehow, telling the truth has become a sign of weakness or incompetence in our society. Poeple who have to stoop to such a low level to try to get elected are to be shunned. People like Ron Paul, Ross Perot and, yes even, Jeremiah Wright all committed the one crime we will not tolerate...they told the truth.

I'm not sure why, I realize I might be better served by spending my time howling at the moon, but could you post a link to the article written by that 'wealthy publican in Sumeria'? I would like to read that too.

2008-12-31 17:17:06
The American Dream
We need to Re-industrialise. We did it during WWII we can do it again. Get rid of the scuflaws and bring in a the new Era.
2008-12-31 17:18:19
I'm convinced that the majority of Americans are decent human beings who simply want a fuller life and a legitimate opportunity for advancement.
Don't disagree or agree. I think people are no different than the animals, living by tooth and claw, but when we separate ourselves from the animals with imagined 'honor' or 'virtue' that doesn't come from hard maintenance efforts, then we forget how primitive we are.
The human is a System of systems which needs feedback to maintain order or it goes 'open-loop' on itself.

That's why we succeed under even oppressive governments and parents: moderation is good for us.

Most of the "American Dream" doesn't go back all that far. It is a marketing slogan invented along with "planned obsolescence" during the late '40's and '50's.
People don't need jobs. They need to simply live and live simply.
2008-12-31 18:02:06
Weak effort by the Minyanville Staff
I don't know about Sumeria, but the Greeks did write about the perils of Democracy, and how only the bullies win. Anyone trying to be honest or nice is not trusted by the public.
2008-12-31 23:25:04
The punchline
"My father's now crossing the threshold into the final stages of his ten-year battle with Alzheimer's disease – a battle he will ultimately lose. And I can't help but contrast the compassion, care, empathy and love he's received from nurses, doctors, aides and ambulance drivers with the selfishness, materialism, egotism and narcissism exhibited by Wall Street scam artists, power-hungry politicians, and pompous government bureaucrats. Dedicated, caring nurses are paid a few thousand dollars per year. Criminally incompetent bank CEOs are paid hundreds of millions per year. Who's helping society more?"

I am sorry for your father's deteriorating health and will keep him in my prayers. The punchline of your comparison between the dedicated health care workers and Wall St. is the fact that Wall St., their insurance company brethren, and the corrupt politicians they control are making it so onerous to continue providing quality health care in this country that our health care system is on the verge of collapse. Their greed, corruption, and incompetence will ultimately destroy that vestige of compassion, care, empathy and love that is the antithesis and so belies their own vile traits.

Unfortunately, we need more than op-ed. We need a revolution of THE PEOPLE and NOW.
Subject:
Comment:
Get real-time options trading ideas from Steve Smith, veteran options trader and newsletter author, plus let him show you the way to cut risk and boost your returns through the strategic use of options.  Click here for a free 14 day trial to OptionSmith by Steve Smith.