Deflationary Hurricane To Hit U.S.

By Mike Mish Shedlock Jun 30, 2008 12:15 pm
Nothing can be done about peak credit.
  • Share this article:
  • A- A A+
Congratulations (of sorts) go to the UK as British household debt is highest in history.

British households are now more indebted than those of any other major country in recorded history, it has emerged.

Families in the UK now owe a record 173pc of their incomes in debts, official figures have shown. The ratio of debt to income is higher than any other country in the Group of Seven leading industrialised economies, and is sharply higher than the 129pc of incomes it was five years ago.

Michael Saunders of Citigroup warned that - at 173pc of household incomes - the debt burden is higher even than Japan's when it peaked in 1990, before more than a decade of deflation. Philip Shaw of Investec said: "Although we take the view that the economy will avoid a recession,
our confidence is ebbing."

Avoid A Recession?

It will be hard for the U.S. and UK to avoid a depression.

What started as a tropical storm called "subprime" has intensified in magnitude to engulf Alt-A mortgages, home equity lines of credit (HELOCs), credit cards, commercial real estate, municipal bonds, corporate bonds and the stock market - just as baby boomers are headed for retirement.

If you prefer, you can think of this as a case of many hurricanes, many eyes.

Barclays Warns Of Financial Storm

Most do not even understand the nature of the storm that is about to hit. Barclays (BCS) is right at the top of the list.

Barclays Capital has advised clients to batten down the hatches for a worldwide financial storm, warning that the US Federal Reserve has allowed the inflation genie out of the bottle and let its credibility fall "below zero."

"We're in a nasty environment," said Tim Bond, the bank's chief equity strategist. "There is an inflation shock underway. This is going to be very negative for financial assets. We are going into tortoise mood and are retreating into our shell. Investors will do well if they can preserve their wealth."

Barclays Capital said in its closely-watched Global Outlook that US headline inflation would hit 5.5pc by August and the Fed will have to raise interest rates six times by the end of next year to prevent a wage-spiral. If it hesitates, the bond markets will take matters into their own hands. "This is the first test for central banks in 30 years and they have fluffed it. They have zero credibility, and the Fed is negative if that's possible. It has lost all credibility," said Mr Bond.



No Wage Price Spiral

Wage price spirals happen when corporations get into bidding wars over employees, not when they're shoving them out the door by the hundreds of thousands. Mr. Bond must be reporting from Bizarro World. The odds of a wage price spiral in the U.S. are essentially zero, since credit is drying up and overcapacity is everywhere you look.

This is not Bizarro World, nor is it 1970.

If Barclays is betting on six interest-rate hikes in the U.S. with its own money, it will likely get carted out in a coffin. Property values are crashing, unemployment is rising, wages are falling, global wage arbitrage is king; most importantly, peak credit has arrived.

It's impossible to get inflation out of that mix. Bernanke could cut interest rates to zero tomorrow and it wouldn't cause inflation, at least as properly defined: A net expansion of money and credit. Banks are strapped for cash. They cannot lend. Businesses do not want to borrow. There is overcapacity everywhere. The shopping center economic model Is history.

I struggle to see how anyone can get inflation out of that mix. Last Thursday, when the stock markets were in freefall, I asked if the inflation scare were over yet.

Well, I guess it's not.


Fed Has Lost Credibility

I will, however, grant Mr. Bond one thing. "The Fed has lost all credibility." I discussed that idea in response to Bernanke's absurd claim that the "danger of downturn appears to have waned."

Bernanke made that statement on June 9th. On June 26th, Bernanke was openly soliciting private equity firms to invest in banks.


Crack-Up Boom In Asia

Actually, I see another statement from Mr. Bond that I agree with, and it's an important one: "Inflation is out of control in Asia. Vietnam has already blown up."

Inflation is indeed out of control in Asia, notably China, India, and Vietnam. That inflation stems from Asia central bankers printing local currency to buy US dollars, in an attempt to keep their export machines going.

Bernanke foolishly calls this a savings glut. Printing money to buy dollars does not constitute savings. It's amazing that a Fed governor does not understand this simple truth.

Besides, it is virtually impossible to have "too much savings". The construct does not even exist!

Peak oil, in conjunction with a crack-up inflationary boom in China, is masking deflation in the U.S. and pending deflation in the U.K. Those focused on rising energy and food prices are missing the boat.

However, I suspect that China's going to slam on the brakes after the Olympics. The Shanghai Stock Exchange Index sure acts as if something is coming down the pike.

$SSEC Weekly Chart


Click to enlarge



Who's In Control?

Ben Bernake at the Fed, Mervyn King at the Bank of England, and Jean-Claude Trichet at the ECB are not in control of what's about to happen. When it comes to commodity prices, peak oil and China's willingness to allow its economy to overheat are going to be the driving forces.

Trichet can hike all he wants, but it won't matter much to the price of oil. However, it may crush individual economies in the EU.

This doesn't mean hiking is wrong (though it likely is); it simply means that hiking to rein in gasoline and food prices, two rather inelastic needs, is beyond silly.


Implications of Peak Credit

When it comes to the collapse in credit, the central banks above are powerless to do a thing about it. That's to be expected, now that we're on the backside of peak credit.

The saturation point has been reached. It took decades, but we've finally arrived.

None of the financial engineering jobs that fueled this credit boom will ever be needed again. Structured investment vehicles (SIVs), conduits, toggle bonds and covenant-lite loans will be dead for years -- if not decades -- to come.

Add to that liar loans, pay-option ARMs, insane leverage and numerous other ridiculous lending arrangements. If those things aren't coming back, we don't need Wall Street shills to securitize the garbage and pitch it to unsuspecting suckers.

In addition to financial engineering jobs, there was a boom in commercial real estate, home depots, remodeling companies, landscaping, furniture, appliances, plumbing, heating, air conditioning, restaurants - and even things like grass seed.

There's no source of jobs to replace what has been lost, nor what will be lost. Discretionary spending is dead.

Boomers about to retire are about to get religion, but sadly, it's too late: Savings they thought they had have now vanished into thin air. It was all a mirage in the first place, but mountains of credit has been extended on the basis of that mirage. Trillions of dollars of imagined wealth has gone up in smoke. Trillions of dollars more are about to.


Deflation Has Set In

It's amusing that in the face of this carnage, many are still screaming inflation, stagflation, or even hyperinflation simply because food and energy prices are rising. Deflation is here and now in the U.S. Deflation is knocking on the door of the UK and the Eurozone. And there's nothing that can be done about it.


Can The Fed Print Its Way Out?

Some will insist that I'm wrong, that the Fed can print. Well, it can print, but it can't spend. Moreover, it can't give money away, nor would it even if it could. Finally, the Fed cannot force banks to lend, nor can it force businesses and consumers to borrow.

Bank credit is contracting with the federal funds rate at 2%. Bank credit wouldn't be going much of anywhere, in my estimation, even at 0%. The reason is simple: Banks are insolvent!

The Fed is like the powerless man behind the curtain in the Wizard of Oz. Once peak credit sets in, all the Fed can do is bluff. The notion of a helicopter drop is pure nonsense.


What About A Crack-Up Boom?

We had a crack-up-boom. What else can you call the financial engineering that went with SIVs, conduits, toggle bonds, covenant-lite loans, pay option ARMs, etc.? That crack-up boom is over.

And just like every credit boom in history, the backside is deflation. Previous examples include Tulip Mania, the South Sea Bubble, the John Law Mississippi scheme, the Great Depression and the property bust in Japan.

Weimar Germany was not a credit boom, but an example of hyperinflation caused by massive printing to pay for war reparations. Zimbabwe is another example of hyperinflation caused by printing.


What About Congress?

Congress, unlike the Fed, can indeed spend money it doesn't have. They've already done so with an ill-advised stimulus package. There will indeed be more stimulus packages, just as there was in Japan.

However, nothing can match the sheer number of jobs created in the housing and commercial real estate booms. And nothing can replace the destruction of wealth that is now taking place in housing and the equity markets.


Attitudes Lead The Way

It took nearly 80 years for people to get as reckless as they did in 1929. 80 years! Few are who went through the Great Depression are still alive. That's the nature of the game. People have to forget what a depression is like to bring about the conditions that cause them. And they did. And they made the same mistakes again - except larger.

The madness of crowds, however, can only go so far. A significant reversal is now underway. The secular peak in consumption has been reached. A reversal in attitudes toward consumption started with houses, but it's spreading to cars, boats and even Starbucks coffee. It will take a long time for attitudes to get back to equilibrium.

And attitudes, like pendulums, will not stop at equilibrium once they get there.

The odds of a significant bout of inflation now are about the same as they were in 1929. Next to none. History is about to repeat.
< Previous
  • 1
Next >
No positions in stocks mentioned.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.

Copyright 2009 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(8)
2008-06-30 13:37:07
Let's get real
The idea that the Fed and Congress are powerless is simply wrong. If Congress wanted to prop up housing they could establish a Federal agency to buy foreclosed houses in depressed areas and bulldoze them. And the Fed could print money and buy Treasuries to fund it. There is nothing unconstitutional about that either.

I'm not proposing that or saying it's wise, but there is absolutely nothing to prevent Congress from doing that. Or any of dozens of other market intervetions.

2008-06-30 13:59:43
Credit deflation=Reduced standard of living
Very good article.

I would argue that the credit bubble allowed for the standard of living to rise artificially high. Now that credit is at "peak credit", the contraction continues. This is why we are seeing deflated asset prices, and will see a reduced standard of living(or at least flat).
I think there is inflation in what we need, because oil is rising. And oil is rising (as Scott points out), because of flat supply, and rising demand from the emerging markets.
The question now is what to do? Cash, zero coupon bonds are great for deflation, but do not protect against rising commodity prices. I have heard gold also rises in deflation?? But I am not a gold expert. Maybe you can ask the gold expert for me?
2008-06-30 14:32:54
Peak Oil Effect?
You mention you believe we are at peak oil.

If this is the case (or about to be the case, as I believe), then the government will have no choice but to go into "Manhattan Project" like spending spree in order to transition the economy off of oil. This will help to fight severe deflationary effects.
Of course:
*Peak oil could be at least a decade or more away-then stagnation or deflation takes hold.
*Peak oil is now, and the government does nothing-what you describe happens.

Since no one has a perfect crystal ball, it might just make sense to start the "Manhattan project" now to secure our economic future. At least the debt will invested in the country and it's future.

If gasoline suddenly rises to $10 a gallon (at the rate it has recently risen), just imagine the economic effect.

2008-06-30 17:28:12
Democrat President & Congress
No limit to what they might do... flailing around they could produce any number of distortions to the marketplace --- no cures, just more problems that take longer for cures.

2008-07-01 01:01:50
Discretionary income?
Oh my! Does this mean there won't be any more buyers for my $50 pinot noirs - just $10 gasoline. And rutabagas. Nasty world. Read Bill Gross' letter to Obama on the Pimco site. Tough love on the part of the righteous might get ugly with so many living paycheck to paycheck. I think we had all better hope we don't have an economic catastrophe because I am nervous about how the 'culture' might respond. Do you suppose people aren't quite as self reliant as they were in the thirties? Wouldn't it all be someone else's fault? Where might that lead? Keep your head down as they say in Bagdad.
2008-07-01 12:38:29
Deficit Spending?
There can be a big difference between how government money is spent. The government, in my opinion, has recently been very wasteful and has simply grown in size.
But government spending to get new industries/infrastructure going/built-up is investment in the country's future. Think of it as R&D spending (or seed capital).
I know this is a tall order for government, but I believe we are now at a point in history where this needs to be done.
2008-07-08 10:19:12
Let the asset deflation roll...
I say so what if assets deflate 30%+. This is an adjustment a long time in coming; needed to match wage gains over the past 2 decades. I've said it before and so I will say it again. My cousins and I could easily get part-time summer jobs in the early 1980's that paid $15 to $20/hour...now try to get one for $12. What does today's $12/hour figure out to in 1981 dollars, backing-out inflation...something in the $3 to $6/hour range? And this does not include the erosion of fringe benefits. Simply put, US wage growth for the middle and lower classes has not kept pace with inflation. The end result is broad-based asset deflation. Maybe my 3 young men can afford a decent home over the next 10 years. Sorry if the gamble scramble in equity and real estate markets will not quite have the pay off for us Boomers and many Golden Agers, many who have already reaped HUGE investment returns in these markets from 1981 to 1999. I think we were too used to 10 to 30% "fast money". It is time for the younger generations to assume the major role of consumer anyway. We had the assets recently to buy the cheap Chinese-made goods to fill the space in our homes. I still have many high-quality, long-lasting, American-made goods purchased from yesteryear's glory days. If the downward wage pressures continue to remain in place, then let assets deflate, nothing more, nothing less. Mike is right on about how far-fetched the wage-spiral-stoking-inflation concern is. Consider the erosion of fringe benefits for many employees in corporate America. Assume companies added the equivalent value in paychecks (+35% burden over base salary). I submit that America's working class inflation-adjusted and fringe benefit-adjusted wages are now so far removed from the 1970 to 1995 historical wage levels that asset deflation has to occur; this, regardless of any form of investment speculation. Many investors choose to view the economy through their own eyes and not through the eyes of the "common working man", so it is no wonder most did not see this coming. Let the good times roll...again...and soon.
2009-11-26 22:13:06
People all over the world know the abercrombie and fitch,but not everyone really knows how fashion the abercrombie is,hollister is the Legend maker. Everybody wears the hollister clothing would be the abercrombie mensand the abercrombie womens, if you want know you can search the Ruehl No.925 or abercrombie outlet in the www.google.com .
Subject:
Comment:
Get real-time options trading ideas from Steve Smith, veteran options trader and newsletter author, plus let him show you the way to cut risk and boost your returns through the strategic use of options.  Click here for a free 14 day trial to OptionSmith by Steve Smith.