What Wealth Effect? QE Has Helped the Rich More Than the Poor
The justification for quantitative easing was a "virtuous" wealth effect that would "promote economic growth" for all to benefit from. But that hasn't happened.
-- Douglas Horton
In November of 2010, Ben Bernanke shocked the world with an unprecedented editorial in the Washington Post (November 4, 2010). In it, he presented the "virtuous" case for an extended period of quantitative easing (emphasis mine):
I remember reading this paragraph over and over again that morning, wondering if I was misinterpreting its message. But there was no mistake about it: For the first time in history, a Fed Chairman was openly admitting to pursuing a policy to pump up the stock market. By itself this would be shocking, but Bernanke was not stopping there. Following the largest housing bubble and collapse in US history which was in large part predicated on the easy monetary policy of his predecessor, Bernanke was essentially advocating the creation of another bubble in housing through lower mortgage rates.
So as of November 2010, we have had explicit Fed policy to re-create the twin bubbles of the late 1990s and mid 2000s in the stock market and housing market. The justification for this policy, of course, was a "virtuous" wealth effect that would "promote economic growth" for all to benefit from. Fast-forward three years and what do we have to show for a Fed funds rate still at 0% and a Fed balance approaching $4 trillion?
1. Stocks: The Fed has largely succeeded in pumping up the stock market, with the Russell 2000 (INDEXRUSSELL:RUT) (NYSEARCA:IWM) at an all-time high, up over 57% since the Bernanke op-ed.
2. Housing: The housing market has also improved, but far less so than the stock market, with the S&P/Case-Shiller 20-City Index Home Price Index up 12% since the Bernanke op-ed but still 21% below its 2006 peak. In recent months, as rates have risen sharply (rates are higher today than at the time of the Bernanke writing), there have been some signs of slowdown. A price ratio of homebuilder stocks relative to the S&P (ITB:SPY) (NYSEARCA:ITB) (NYSEARCA:SPY) illustrates this slowdown, declining since May and below the QE3 announcement last September. As a reminder, a rising price ratio means the numerator/ITB is outperforming (up more/down less) the denominator/SPY.
3. Economy: As for the virtuous "wealth effect" leading to economic growth, well, you be the judge. Year-over-year real GDP is running at 1.6%, a level more typically associated with the beginning of a recession rather than four years into an expansion (see the first chart below). Real median household income tells a similar story, up less than 1% from the Bernanke op-ed and still well below levels over 13 years ago (see the second chart below).
Source: Doug Short
Source: Doug Short
What's the bottom line of all this?
In 2010, we were told by Chairman Bernanke that QE would spur a "virtuous circle" where higher stock and housing prices would lead to increased spending and economic growth. The evidence since then has supported only one-third of this circle: significantly higher stock prices. This, of course, has disproportionately helped the wealthy, who own the vast majority of financial assets. Bizarro Robin Hood is causing the wealth gap to widen to extremes, leaving many disenchanted by stock market gains.
While the housing market has improved from historically depressed levels, it remains over 20% below its 2006 peak, and there have been signs recently of a renewed slowdown. Also, in spite of unprecedented buying of mortgage bonds by the Fed, mortgage rates stand higher today than in November of 2010.
As for the real economy, growth remains anemic and the average household (real median income) is still faring worse today than at the supposed end of the last recession. As Stan Druckenmiller said on CNBC in September after the Fed's no taper decision, "This is fantastic for every rich person. This is the biggest redistribution of wealth from the middle class and the poor to the rich ever."
Perhaps this is the Chairman's definition of virtuous.
This writing is for informational purposes only and does not constitute an offer to sell, a solicitation to buy, or a recommendation regarding any securities transaction, or as an offer to provide advisory or other services by Pension Partners, LLC in any jurisdiction in which such offer, solicitation, purchase or sale would be unlawful under the securities laws of such jurisdiction. The information contained in this writing should not be construed as financial or investment advice on any subject matter. Pension Partners, LLC expressly disclaims all liability in respect to actions taken based on any or all of the information on this writing.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.
Copyright 2011 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.