As long-time readers know, I have been primarily bullish on equities since November 2012. But for the first time since then, I truly have no desire to "buy the dip" for anything longer than a short-term trade. There are some disturbing early warning signs that the market may be undergoing a fundamental change of character.
I don't presently know how long this will last, but when I see signals like this from the market, I don't screw around and risk gambling away my financial future. One of my trading mottos is "when in doubt, get out." I have often likened trading to poker -- and one of the mathematical concepts required to become a winning poker player is an understanding of "pot odds," which is the ratio of the current pot to the cost of calling a bet. Simply put: If the pot is $100, and calling costs $10, then the pot odds are 10:1. Trading is all about odds as well.
While I'm simplifying this analogy by overlooking concepts such as implied odds, etc., the next mathematical requirement in poker is to calculate the odds your hand has of actually winning the pot. Then one compares those odds against the pot odds, and folds or calls (or raises) accordingly. For example, if your hand will win one in five times, and the pot odds are 10:1, then calling a bet is a winning play over the long term. But if your hand will only win one in 20 times while the pot odds are still 10:1, then the correct play is to fold if someone bets, and wait to try again next round. (Incidentally, this is also why you want to bet aggressively and don't want to "check" a winning hand; if you don’t bet, you are giving your opponents infinite odds to draw to their long-shots for free against you.)
In order to become a winning poker player over the long-term, one doesn't gamble, but plays each hand with discipline and according to the odds. Oftentimes, inexperienced players will stay in the game despite the odds stacked against them -- usually this is because they either don't understand the math, or because they like "being in the action" and lack discipline. Sometimes, in spite of their poor play, they'll win in the end -- odds are only odds after all, so even bad odds are mathematically required to win occasionally. Unfortunately, the thrill and reward of these occasional wins encourages bad players to continue playing incorrectly, and -- worse -- often leads them to believe that their lack of discipline was actually pure, unadulterated brilliance. The problem is that over the long haul players who have no discipline will, without exception, eventually end up 100% dead broke -- and that is a mathematical certainty. I view trading in much the same light, and traders who lack discipline and overplay their weak hands will certainly end up broke as well.
All that to say, while the market always reserves the right to prove me wrong and go on to new highs immediately, I feel the odds are very good that there are ultimately lower lows still ahead. Note that a near-term reaction rally could begin as early as today's session, but unless the market does something to shift the ball back to the bulls, given what I see today, I would expect the next rally will be sold. Since the best we can do is attempt to play the odds correctly, here are a few statistics and observations to consider:
1. The Volatility Index
(INDEXCBOE:VIX) rose more than 30% in the last two sessions. Nearly 90% of the time this has happened previously in the past 20+ years, the market has subsequently gone on to make lower lows before making higher highs. Interestingly, the ferocity of the recent VIX decline also argues for a near-term snap back rally, beginning as early as today's session.
2. Precious metals have been absolutely slaughtered lately (I'll work up some PM charts over the next few updates), which means the market is at least considering the thought of a deflationary environment. Further, the extreme volatility in PMs can often be a warning signal that things are about to become more volatile for equities as well.
3. The momentum lows we saw yesterday are rarely reached in exact tandem with the actual price low, and generally we'd expect to see a bullish divergence before price finds a meaningful bottom. Additionally, the up-volume to down volume ratio was high enough that we would expect to see further downside and new lows in the reasonably near future.
Let's start off with the S&P 500
(INDEXSP:.INX) chart. I've outlined my best-guess for a market path that presently appears reasonable to my eye, but do please note that predicting an exact path with the market in this position is exceedingly difficult, so don't be surprised if it deviates.
As I mentioned yesterday
, there is currently the potential of five complete waves up from the November lows, which usually means we can expect see a correction begin.
(If you're new to Elliott Wave Theory, I have written a primer article
on the subject.)
Click to enlarge
I spent several hours working with the Philadelphia Bank Index
(INDEXDJX:BKX) last night, since BKX has been a great leading indicator. The chart below outlines one of the remaining bear options for the long-term: If BKX is forming a massive triangle, it will ultimately go on to new lows beneath the 2009 low -- though it would first grind around sideways/down (relative to the size of the pattern) over the intermediate term. The chart below outlines the next important long-term levels.
Click to enlarge
BKX is one of the markets I've been keeping a very close eye on for several months. A few weeks ago, I made reference to the possibility that a number of markets may be completing extended fifth wave rallies, and BKX was one of the markets I had in mind during that discussion. I have never been satisfied with the summer-2012 rally as a complete five-wave structure, and the decline into November also did not overlap the potential red wave (i) peak, which keeps the extended fifth wave viable. Though it's too early to say with certainty, the chart below does outline some signals and price levels.
Click to enlarge
In conclusion, it's still a bit early to call an intermediate top, but there are numerous warning signals indicating that the "pot odds" seem to be shifting into the bears' favor. Accordingly, I think bulls will want to stay exceptionally cautious and nimble up here, and may want to consider standing aside entirely for the time being. In the next few updates, we'll also take a closer look at precious metals. Trade safe.
No positions in stocks mentioned.
The information on this website solely reflects the analysis of or opinion about the performance of securities and financial markets by the writers whose articles appear on the site. The views expressed by the writers are not necessarily the views of Minyanville Media, Inc. or members of its management. Nothing contained on the website is intended to constitute a recommendation or advice addressed to an individual investor or category of investors to purchase, sell or hold any security, or to take any action with respect to the prospective movement of the securities markets or to solicit the purchase or sale of any security. Any investment decisions must be made by the reader either individually or in consultation with his or her investment professional. Minyanville writers and staff may trade or hold positions in securities that are discussed in articles appearing on the website. Writers of articles are required to disclose whether they have a position in any stock or fund discussed in an article, but are not permitted to disclose the size or direction of the position. Nothing on this website is intended to solicit business of any kind for a writer's business or fund. Minyanville management and staff as well as contributing writers will not respond to emails or other communications requesting investment advice.
Copyright 2011 Minyanville Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved.